X
PrevPrev Go to previous topic
NextNext Go to next topic
Last Post 26 Jul 2011 07:58 AM by  anon
Orthorectifing GeoEye Data - RPCs + DEM + GCPs
 2 Replies
Sort:
You are not authorized to post a reply.
Author Messages

anon



New Member


Posts:
New Member


--
26 Jul 2011 07:58 AM
    Hello, I have: 1 - SRTM DEM 2 - GeoEye-1 - GeoProduct with RPCs 3 - Reference BaseMap of the area (Generated from Orthophoto ) I ran the orthorectification GeoEye-1 image using only RPC and SRTM DEM, and got a great result, with an almost perfect alignment between the image and the Reference BaseMap. Additionally, did the collection of 9 GCPs in Reference BaseMap to run the RPC orthorectification with SRTM DEM + RPCs + GCPs. (The GCPs were with 0.9 RMS when inserted in the image.) However, the result of orthorectification using 9 GCPs, had a worse result than the orthorectification without GCPs. There was not the expected alignment between the image and ReferenceBaseMap using the GCPs. Why is the result of orthorectification with GCPs may have been worse than the result without GCPs?

    Deleted User



    New Member


    Posts:
    New Member


    --
    24 Apr 2012 02:17 PM
    Hi Ramon, I had the same problem, but orthorectifying a Kompsat image. No answer till the moment, I have seen that Envi changes to geographic coordinates (lat long), the header of your control point file. I did the same thing in Erdas imagine and it worked. I'm very dissapointed about Envi....

    Deleted User



    New Member


    Posts:
    New Member


    --
    25 Apr 2012 07:57 AM
    If the x, y, and/or z values for the GCPs are less accurate than the x, y, and/or z coordinates that the orthorectification without GCPs calculates, then the GCPs will indeed make the orthorectification worse. ENVI assumes that the GCPs are *more* accurate, and so it takes the ortho results and adjusts them to match the GCP coordinates. So you always want to make sure that the GCP coordinates you provide are very accurate, or it's better to not use them. Another thing that can happen is that sometimes people get confused about which coordinate system is being used when specifying the x and y coordinates of their GCPs. For example, sometimes people will not notice that the dialog specifies lat/long for the coordinate system, and they'll enter points using coordinates for a map projection. Also, if you select a point in the list, and then use the Goto button to jump to that point, the map projection in the GCP Selection dialog can automatically change to lat/long without you noticing. If you then add additional points, you need to specify their coordinates in lat/long, even if you were previously entering them in, say, UTM. To make sure something like this isn't happening, you'll want to keep a close eye on your map coordinates in the list of GCPs in your GCP selection dialog. Make sure they are all in the same coordinate system, and that it is the coordinate system specified in the GCP Selection dialog . Many of these potential pitfalls have been cleaned up, so the whole process is less potentially confusing, in the upcoming ENVI 5 release. Right now, we expect ENVI 5 to be available for download from the Exelis VIS web site on May 1. - Peg
    You are not authorized to post a reply.